A
Doctor's Dilemma -- Facing Aids With Empty Pockets
By Dr. Somnuek Sungkanuparph, Pacific News Service, July 26,
2000
Nothing
is more painful and frustrating to a doctor than knowing how
to treat a patient but lacking the resources to do so. But that
is the everyday reality for physicians in Thailand, where an
estimated million of the country's 60 million have AIDS. PNS
commentator Dr. Somnuek Sungkanuparph is with the Infectious
Disease Unit, Department of Medicine, Ramathibodi Hospital,
Bangkok, Thailand
Only a few doctors in my class at medical school went into
the field of infectious diseases, including HIV and AIDS.
This is not because they fear infection but because they know
that caring for the patient with HIV or AIDS brings the highest
level of frustration -- they know most patients cannot afford
anti-viral drugs.
The more data I see about HIV being a treatable disease, the
more frustrated I become. It is excruciating as a doctor to
know how to care for a patient but be unable to do so.
I now have 60 to 80 patients infected with HIV and about 40
patients in the AIDS stage. About half these patients cannot
afford anti-viral drugs. Many of the HIV-infected patients
are age 25 to 35 with incomes below 5,000 baht (US. 125) a
month -- including 10 patients with no job at all who are
supported by relatives or a non-profit organization.
Thailand's first epidemic of HIV happened in 1985, but the
government did not acknowledge how dire the situation was
until 1992, when 500,000 people were infected with HIV.
At first, we had success with a condom and education campaign,
and the number of those infected with HIV began to decline.
But just last year the number of new cases began to rise again.
Now it is estimated that almost 1 million people are infected
with HIV in Thailand, and the most common method of transmission
is through heterosexual sex.
The government no longer subsidizes medicine for anti-viral
therapy as they did when the standard treatment involved a
mix of two drugs. The new, best medication is very expensive
and the government can no longer afford to pay for the drugs.
There is just too much demand. Frankly, only about 10 percent
to 20 percent of the population can afford the anti-viral
therapy -- even if I were infected with HIV, I could not afford
the medicine.
We have petitioned the drug companies to lower the price of
the anti-viral drugs, but they have not listened. I go with
this information to organizations like San Francisco General
Hospital's HIV/AIDS care unit and the World AIDS conference
in Durban, South Africa. It's a chance to reach out to doctors,
researchers and social workers to help me influence the drug
companies.
This is not a profit issue, but a human one. If the drug companies
can decrease the price of the remedies, then they can sell
more drugs and profits will not decrease much. They disagree,
for very silly reasons, saying that if they decrease the price
in Thailand, people from other countries will flock to Thailand
to buy the medicine. How many people will do that? That's
not the real reason.
I also know that the country has the funds to help patients
get treatment for such ailments as heart disease, but very
few people will set up funds for HIV and AIDS. The prevailing
attitude here is that the disease is something you brought
on yourself, and it did not occur naturally. Some doctors
view it as punishment. As a result many patients are abandoned
and others don't care.
My priority is also to teach my students about the AIDS problem.
This may not influence the AIDS epidemic now, but perhaps
in the future it will help. I can inform my students about
HIV and not let them walk away from it.
I am beginning to record data about the patients in my HIV
clinic with the help of four other doctors in my unit, and
we will use this to inform other organizations in the world.
My mentor/professor is trying to push me into the AIDS Center
of Thailand's Ministry of Health meeting. I feel like I should
take the chance and go in.
And every time we treat a patient we try to educate them and
their families, and the circle widens.
I'm not sure what more I can do. It's just the beginning of
my efforts. I may fail, but at least I am trying.
|