Positive
Psychology -- An Idea Whose Time Has Come (Again)
By
Walter Truett Anderson, Pacific News Service, September 20,
2000
We see psychology basically as the study of trouble --
an attempt to discover reasons for unhappiness or destructive
behavior, and the like. But a new, or rather revived, movement
is more concerned with the other side, and proposes clinical
examination of those who are happy and move easily in the
world. PNS associate editor Walter Truett Anderson is the
author of "The Future of the Self" (Tarcher Putnam, 1997).
Ask the average person what psychology is about and he or
she is likely to answer that it's about mental illness --
anxiety, depression, obsession, compulsion, and so on down
the long, bleak laundry list of human discontents. Unfortunately,
the average person is likely to be dead-on right.
From
Sigmund Freud to B. F. Skinner to the authors of today's Diagnostic
and Statistical Manuals of Mental Disorders, mainstream psychology
is mainly a matter of accentuating the negative. Sure, there
have always been dissenting voices -- such as the late Abraham
Maslow, who throughout the 1960s tried to get his colleagues
to pay attention to peak experiences and self-actualizing
people (that is, people who are healthy and fully functioning)
-- but they have always been in the minority.
Establishment
psychologists, on the whole, tend to get nervous when people
start talking about such matters as love, optimism, joy, courage
and kindness. All those subjects are dismissed as "pop psychology,"
more suitable for gushy self-help books than for serious scientific
study.
But
over the past couple of years, another group of dissidents
has hoisted the flag under the name "positive psychology."
The
leading spokesman and tactician of the new counter-movement
is Dr. Martin Seligman of the University of Pennsylvania.
Two years ago, during a term as president of the American
Psychological Association, he accused his colleagues of having
allowed their profession to turn into a "victimology." Most
psychological research, he claimed, tends to regard human
beings as little more than passive objects buffeted about
by events, and most psychotherapies tend to treat mental illness
"within a theoretical framework of repairing damaged habits,
damaged drives, damaged childhoods and damaged brains."
"Psychology,"
he insisted, "is not just the study of weakness and damage,
it is also the study of strength and virtue. Treatment is
not just fixing what is broken, it is nurturing what is best
within ourselves."
Different
people who rally to the positive psychology cause have different
ideas about what real mental health is and how it can best
be cultivated. However, what basically unites them is the
conviction that normal human beings possess a great deal more
strength and resilience than they are usually given credit
for, and that -- however much we may be affected by events
beyond our control or by elements of our genetic heritage
-- we are capable of making meaningful choices about what
we do and how we feel.
Seligman's
own favorite theme is optimism. He claims there is a significant
body of evidence that optimistic people are happier and more
productive than pessimists. Furthermore, he believes that
optimism can be learned and taught. He has written books on
this subject -- with titles such as "Learned Optimism" and
"The Optimistic Child" -- and has even developed a curriculum
for teaching practical optimism in the schools.
Another
leader in the positive psychology movement is the Hungarian-born
Mihalyi Csikszentmihalyi of the University of Chicago, whose
thinking focuses on certain kinds of optimum experience he
calls "flow." Flow is about the way people feel when they
are doing something really well, or simply enjoying a pursuit
so much that they lose themselves in it.
In
Csikszentmihalyi's view, flow is as real a part of human life
as, say, depression, and he believes that a better understanding
of it -- grounded in hard research -- can change the way people
do their work or, for that matter, their goofing off.
Research
is an all-important part of the positive psychology movement,
the means by which its leaders such as Seligman and Csikszentmihalyi
-- and the many younger psychologists who are signing on to
the cause -- hope to convert their colleagues. Research is
also the means to distance themselves from the writers of
spiritual chicken soup books, and find some practical ways
to increase the human sum of joy, hope, strength and courage
while we busy ourselves making so many kinds of progress in
the world.
|