Table of Contents
| Jinn Home Page
| Search
| Net-Links
Voices
| Heresies
| Vectors
| Pacific Pulse
| The Americas
| California
| Movements
| Civil Conflicts
| YO!

Rankism -- The Mother Of All Isms
By Robert W. Fuller
Date: 10-06-00
In America's celebrity culture, "somebodies" are sought
after, given preference, lionized. "Nobodies" get insulted, dissed, exploited,
ignored. The syndrome might be called rankism. PNS correspondent Robert
W. Fuller taught physics at Columbia, created a program for high school
dropouts in Seattle and served as president of Oberlin. His book,
"Rankism: Breaking Ranks in Pursuit of Individual Dignity," can be
accessed at www.breakingranks.net.
An executive pulls up to valet parking at a restaurant, late to a
business lunch, and finds no one to take his car keys. Anxious and
fuming, he spots a teenager running toward him in the rear-view mirror
and yells, "Where the hell were you? I haven't got all day."
He tosses the keys in the kid's general direction and they fall to the
pavement. Bending to pick them up, the boy says, "Sorry, sir. About how
long do you expect to be?"
The executive hollers over his shoulder, "You'll know when you see me,
won't you?" The valet winces, but holds his tongue. Postscript: the
teenager goes home and bullies his kid brother.
It's easy to multiply examples like these: a customer demeans a
waitress,
a coach bullies a player, a doctor disparages a nurse, a school
principal
insults a teacher, a teacher humiliates a student, students ostracize
other students, a parent belittles a child, an officer abuses a
suspect,
a professor exploits a teaching assistant, a boss harasses an employee,
a
caretaker mistreats an invalid.
Most such behaviors have nothing to do with racism or sexism. Yet the
effect on the victims is no different from how it felt to be Jewish,
black, or gay until things began to change for those groups. The
perpetrators of these insults, like racists and sexists, select their
targets with circumspection. In each of these examples, what triggers
uneaqual treatment is rank -- rank as measured on the somebody-nobody
scale.
"Somebodies" are sought after, given preference, lionized. "Nobodies"
get
insulted, dissed, exploited, ignored. Low rank, even when the ranking
is
clearly meretricious, functions exactly like race and gender -- as an
unjustifiable impediment to advancement.
All forms of abuse, prejudice, and discrimination are actually
predicated
upon differences in rank. Rank-based discrimination deserves a name of
its own to distinguish it from racism, sexism, and bad manners. By
analogy, we shall call it rankism. Once you have a name for it you see
it
everywhere.
Our society no longer condones abuse based on race or gender, but
inequity based on rank is, for the most part, still overlooked. It
might
be supposed that if one overcomes tendencies to racism, sexism, ageism
and other narrowly defined forms of prejudice, one would be purged of
rankism as well. But rankism is not just another ism, it's the mother
of
them all. The familiar kinds of discrimination are simply special cases
of rankism. Color, gender, etc. are excuses for exploiting power
differences, not the cause of the resulting injustices.
Unlike race or gender, rank is mutable. You can be taken for a nobody
one
day and for a somebody the next. You can be a nobody at home and a
somebody at work, or vice versa. "Nobody" is an epithet used to justify
further denigration and inequity. "Nobody" is the N-word of our time.
Much of what's labeled social pathology arises from rankism. The
indignity suffered by nobodies festers. It turns to indignation and
sometimes erupts in violence. To "nobody" individuals, or a people, is
not only to do them an injustice, it is to plant a time bomb in our own
midst.
The consequences range from school shootings to revanchism, even
genocide. The 20th century has seen many demagogues who have promised
to
restore the pride and dignity of a people that felt "nobodied." Hitler
enjoyed the support of Germans humiliated by punitive measures in the
aftermath of World War I. President Milosevic of Yugoslavia has traded
on
the wounded pride of the Serbs. People will become apologists for
crimes
they would otherwise condemn to get even with those they believe have
nobodied them.
Attacking the familiar isms, one at a time, is like lopping heads off
the
Hydra of discrimination and prejudice. Going after rankism, which
underlies all forms of discrimination, would drive a stake through the
Hydra's heart.
In targeting rankism, it is vital to recognize that there is nothing
wrong with rank per se, any more than there is anything wrong with race
or with gender. When it has been earned and signifies excellence, rank
is
generally accepted.
But when rank is exercised beyond its appropriate domain, or when
others
are "nobodied," that's rankism. The democratic process provides a
recourse to rankism in civic affairs, but in the workplace and in
education we must often knuckle under or risk our position.
Before the civil rights and women's movements, blatant forms of race
and
gender-based discrimination were mostly condoned. Now, being labeled a
"racist" or a "sexist," a "bigot" or a homophobe," does not look good
on
your resume.
In contrast, rankism, in both its interpersonal and institutional
guises,
still enjoys wide tacit support. Overcoming rankism -- in the family,
the
schools, health care and the workplace -- is democracy's next step.

Pacific News Service,
660 Market Street, Room 210, San Francisco, CA 94104,
tel: (415) 438-4755.
Jinn Magazine: <http://www.pacificnews.org/jinn/>
Email:
<pacificnews@pacificnews.org>
Copyright © 1900 Pacific News Service. All Rights Reserved.
Please do not reprint our stories without our permission.
This article is available for reprint.
For rates and information, call (415) 438-4755 or e-mail
<pacificnews@pacificnews.org>
|