Table of Contents
| Jinn Home Page
| Search
| Net-Links
Voices
| Heresies
| Vectors
| Pacific Pulse
| The Americas
| California
| Movements
| Civil Conflicts
| YO!

Lifting The Islamic Woman's Veil, Part II
By Muddassir Rizvi, Hadia Nusrat And Fariba Nawa
Date: 02-28-01
Today, Pacific News Service offers the third and fourth
parts of a four-part series that lifts the veil of stereotype from
Islamic women's lives. For instance, despite the strenuous objections of
religious conservatives, women are taking seats in local government
councils in Pakistan as part of a program enunciated by the country's
military leaders. More than 4,000 were elected in a first round and there
is a widespread feeling that the world will never be quite the same, say
PNS commentators Muddassir Rizvi and Hadia Nusrat. Rizvi is a Pakistani
journalist specializing in development issues; Nusrat works with an
Islamibad-based public health publication. For PNS contributor Fariba
Nawa, author of the second piece, the last 20 years have been
particularly unkind. The daughter of exiles raised in America, who is old
enough to remember but gone long enough to forget, she returns to
Afghanistan, providing a series of unsettling contrasts. Nawa travels
frequently to the Middle East and South Asia.
WOMEN TAKE LOCAL OFFICE IN PAKISTAN UNDER UNLIKELY AUSPICES OF MILITARY RULERS
BY MUDDASSIR RIZVI AND HADIA NUSRAT, PACIFIC NEWS SERVICE
"Having women representatives will promote obscenity," declared Maulvi
Allah Bakhsh, who leads prayers at a mosque in a small village near the
town of Sargodha, a four-hour drive from Pakistan's capital, Islamabad.
Allah Bakhsh represents the dissent emanating mainly from right -wing
religious parties against women taking local political seats allocated to
them by the military government.
"Islam restricts women from 'intermingling with men' other than
relatives," he explains, "and holds that women should stay at home and
shouldn't be allowed politicking."
But this did not deter Fatima Bibi, newly elected councilor from the same
village. "Things are going to change," she says. Bibi is among 4,689
women elected in the 18 most backward of Pakistan's 110 districts in the
first phase of local elections. The second phase, involving 23 districts,
begins March 21, and the third and final round ends August 14.
This is part of the military government's planned devolution of power
aimed at introducing true democracy to this country of 135 million people.
It also heralds an era of women's empowerment in a country that has been
under fire for rights abuses and discrimination against women. As it
tries to gain more acceptability in the international community, the
military government has placed major emphasis on improving human rights
here, especially for women and minorities.
But even this first step was not easy. When the government announced last
March that women were to be given half the seats in the traditionally
male-dominated local level institutions, it was met with sharp criticism
from religious parties and Islamic extremist groups.
"The plan to give representation to women at the village council level is
a conspiracy to mutilate the ideological spirit of the country," said
Maulana Shah Ahmed Noorani, who heads the Milli Yakjehti Council (MYC), a
coalition of more than 15 Islamic parties.
The MYC threatened the military rulers with countrywide agitation. This
forced the government to cut down the number of reserved seats to 33
percent.
But that did not satisfy the Islamists. In many parts of the country,
religious parties ran concerted campaigns to discourage women from
participating in local elections, using family and social pressure. In
the mountainous Dir district in the northwest, one extremist Islamic
party, closely linked with Afghanistan's Taliban rulers, physical
threatened physical harm to women's rights activists.
Even more moderate segments of the right wing oppose women's
emancipation. "If the need arises, women can work outside their homes on
the condition that their domestic duties are not compromised," says Dr.
Zafar Ansari, Director of the Islamic Research Institute in Islamabad.
Aside from religious pressures, men in the families -- especially in
influential families -- see women leaving the house as a matter of loss
of prestige.
Against this backdrop, almost 20 percent of the reserved women's seats
remained vacant after the recent vote. Fatima Bibi, whose retired
military husband fully supports her political endeavors, is undeterred by
opposition. The 39-year-old mother of six is bracing herself to raise
issues as diverse as high rates of female illiteracy, poor maternal
health facilities, and non-availability of clean water.
"We have no fearwe'll fight for our rights," she said amidst approving
nods of women of the village gathered around her at the office of the
Pattan Development Foundation, which has been working on voters education
for the past three months.
Pattan field staff had played a key role in motivating women in 12
villages of the area. "The process was painstaking," said a Pattan
volunteer Fida Hussain, camped in a mud house near the banks of the
Chenab River. "We involved the men and elders of the family in allowing
their women to take on the role of participation in decision-making. As
women's participation is a sensitive issue, we tried to make our
intervention culturally acceptable and closer to the people's value
systems."
Pattan is not alone. Aurat Foundation, a Lahore-based women's rights
group, formed district level committees to ensure maximum women's
participation.
A report by the Mahboob ul Haq Centre for Human Development found at
least 29 percent of Pakistani females are deprived of health care,
whereas an alarming 72 percent -- as against 47 per cent of males -- have
no educational opportunities.
In Fatima's village, the only girls' primary school in the has no
teacher, making religious education at the mosque the only choice. Nor
are there facilities to address maternal health problems. A
government-paid health worker does not enjoy the confidence of the local
population, because she is young and inexperienced.
"The nearest basic health unit is more than 20 km (12 miles) away," said
Bashiraan Bibi, whose husband lost the election on the peasant seat by a
narrow margin. "Many women, especially those with complications, lose
their lives since the only transport available is a horse-pulled cart."
But these women now see a ray of hope in Fatima and other women
councilors making their voices heard. These women are still a long way
from real empowerment. "Change is a slow processbut at least the ball
has been set rolling," said a confident Fida Hussain.
Much will depend on whether or not the government honors its promise of
devolving powers to these local representatives as the only way to
introduce good governance in a country that is marred by corruption and
bureaucratic inefficiencies.
AFTER 20 YEARS: GOING HOME TO A STRANGE AND FAMILIAR LAND
BY FARIBA NAWA, PACIFIC NEWS SERVICE
Buzzing flies circled my face. As I swatted them away, I slowly looked up
to see nearly a dozen men staring intently at my face and hands -- the
only bared parts of my body. I was dressed in compliance with Iran's code
for women, I was standing in line at the Iranian border waiting to cross
into my hometown of Herat, Afghanistan.
I kept my eyes to the floor to avoid the looks until the border agent
called my name. My hands trembled as I handed him my Afghan passport --
perhaps the least useful travel document in the world. Soon, I would be
home again after nearly 20 years.
My family fled Afghanistan during the Soviet invasion when I was eight
years old in 1981. We escaped to California, where I grew up. Although I
am Americanized, Afghanistan is in my heart and memories. I pictured
myself returning to my grandfather's home, where my cousins and I used to
play and eat the fruit we picked from his orchards. His five-acre home
was a sanctuary from our neighborhood, where the boom of rockets and
bullets echoed in the backyard.
The war has turned into a civil war now as the Afghans struggle to
survive in the wake of more United Nations sanctions. One of the poorest
countries in the world, Afghanistan is facing a severe drought as well as
threat of starvation.
In the name of religion, the Taliban -- the militia ruling the majority
of the country -- forbid women from going to school or working in most
fields and force men to pray. Women must travel with a male relative
(mahram) and wear a burqa, which covers the body like a tent with only a
mesh for sight. Men must sport untrimmed, scraggly beards. This was the
Afghanistan I was about to enter with my cousin's best friend, Mobin, as
my rented mahram.
Mobin was a merchant, who traveled across Iran and Afghanistan selling
buttons and lace. He saw his wife and 18-month-old son in Herat one week
out of the month. Shrewd and experienced, Mobin promised to take me from
Iran to Afghanistan and finally, Pakistan.
With my American passport hidden under my bra, I held my breath as we
passed through Taliban customs. We rented a taxi with two other women --
Mobin was also their mahram -- and though the Taliban banned music, the
taxi driver popped in the latest Afghan folk songs and increased the
volume as we headed toward Herat. This ancient city once known for its
art and culture in Central Asia is now the only Afghan city with a
functioning economy.
As the station wagon rolled up and down the desert sand dunes, I took out
my journal and wrote under my black coat. Every time a man appeared in
the distance, we women covered our faces with the edge of our
headscarves. "Don't worry -- the Taliban are scared of women," Mobin
said. "They usually stop cars with men. The ones with women, they turn
their heads."
We decided to don the burqa once we reached the city. I closed my eyes,
smelled the air and listened to the folk singer, recorded in Virginia,
lamenting his distance from his homeland. But I was finally home.
Two hours later in pitch dark, we entered the gates of the city. High
adobe walls hid the houses, but downtown was lit in neon. Men rode their
bicycles on the unpaved roads. It was 10 p.m. and there was not a woman
in sight.
The taxi stopped in front of Mobin's house, I stepped down and kissed the
ground, then looked up at the sky. The fall breeze blew the dust in my
eyes, but I could still see the constellations, shooting stars and the
moon.
The people I knew in Herat were distant relatives except for my
step-grandmother, who still lives on our land. Only my mother's uncle
knew I was coming because he was one of the few who owned a telephone.
I stayed with his two wives and their children. They were fairly well off
and rebellious, defying the Taliban's ban on music and television. They
had a satellite dish on their porch, a television and musical instruments
in the basements. My five female cousins, mostly teen-agers, did not go
to clandestine home schools as did some girls.
This family's attitude toward the Taliban, typical of Heratis, accepts
the limitations in exchange for peace. However, they want Ismail Khan,
the warlord who ruled Herat before the militia, restored to power. While
other warlords, once freedom fighters against the Russians, fought each
other, Ismail Khan began to develop Herat. He was corrupt, but better
than the Taliban, according to my relatives.
The ruling militia has instilled a chilling fear in Afghans, especially
women. Since Herat is the Taliban's base for money, they give its
residents more leeway and Heratis take advantage of this in a
schizophrenic manner. My cousins would drum on their tambourines at
midnight, cursing the Taliban as they sang. The next day, the girls
whispered in conversation, afraid the Taliban were coming to get them.
One way of appeasing the Taliban was to invite their local leaders to
parties, where they joined in the festivity.
I kept a low profile, staying inside most of the time. I fit in
surprisingly well despite my liberal ideas and informal manner. My
relatives assumed I had forgotten the Persian language and Islam, both of
which I have kept.
On the second day of my journey, I put on the burqa and went into the
streets for the first time with my cousins. I walked slowly, worried that
I might trip on the flowing fabric. There is an ironic power in being
invisible. Men in public noticed my ankles and hands, but did not look at
my eyes. I stared at their expressions and actions without their
knowledge.
We first rode a decorated Toyota Corolla taxi, then a horse wagon to
reach my family home. I knocked at the old brass gate. A child opened the
door and led me to my grandmother. She was praying. I lifted the front of
my burqa as she turned her head. My grandmother, 70, screamed in
disbelief as if I were a ghost. She passed out for a few seconds before
hugging me and sobbed on my shoulders.
The next few days passed so quickly in gleeful activity. I went shopping,
visited shrines and the school I attended until I witnessed a bomb kill
my second-grade classmates.
Saving the best for last, I stepped into the orchard home on the seventh
day of my visit. I threw my burqa on the ground and sprinted toward the
living quarters, hearing my family's laughter inside the hallways.
But the doors to the 11 rooms were locked and some of their windows
broken.
I ran out to the field, frantically looking for the mulberry and
pomegranate trees where we used to picnic. I found the trees, but no
fruit, due to the drought. The entire place seemed much smaller. I kept
running into walls. Then I remembered hearing that my uncles sold three
acres.
My happy nostalgia turned into despair. I climbed the roof overlooking
the city and wept.
The tears were a catharsis, an acceptance of the past as past. My
distance from Herat for these 20 years had a left void in me. I was
missing something as I had lived my comfortable Western life in San
Francisco. But 10,000 miles away, leaning at the edge of my childhood
roof, I felt a sense of completion.

Pacific News Service,
660 Market Street, Room 210, San Francisco, CA 94104,
tel: (415) 438-4755.
Jinn Magazine: <http://www.pacificnews.org/jinn/>
Email:
<pacificnews@pacificnews.org>
Copyright © 1900 Pacific News Service. All Rights Reserved.
Please do not reprint our stories without our permission.
This article is available for reprint.
For rates and information, call (415) 438-4755 or e-mail
<pacificnews@pacificnews.org>
|