Table of Contents
| Jinn Home Page
| Search
| Net-Links
Voices
| Heresies
| Vectors
| Pacific Pulse
| The Americas
| California
| Movements
| Civil Conflicts
| YO!

Was FBI Agent's True "Loyalty" To Opus Dei?
By Yoichi Clark Shimatsu
Date: 03-05-01
The mystery within the mystery concerning Robert Hanssen,
accused of spying for the Soviet Union for more than 15 years, is simply
what motivated him to do it? With no signs of pro-Soviet ideological
commitment or extravagant spending, the answer may lie in Hanssen's
membership in Opus Dei, an ultraconservative Catholic organization. PNS
commentator Yoichi Clark Shimatsu is former editor of The Japan Times
Weekly in Tokyo, and has reported on the Aum Shinrikyo sect.
Intelligence experts and congressional committees are puzzling over what
motivated FBI agent Robert Hanssen to spy for Moscow over the past 15
years.
Money seems to offer no clues, because Hanssen lived in an ascetic style.
Nor is there yet any evidence that this happily married man fell into a
"honey trap" involving a coy Natasha.
The search for a motive is complicated by the fact that his colleagues
say that Hanssen was fiercely anticommunist and a devout member of Opus
Dei, an ultraconservative Catholic organization. He was a regular
parishioner of St. Catherine of Siena Church, in a Virginia suburb of the
capital, where an elite congregation, which includes Supreme Court
justice Antonia Scalia, attend traditional Latin masses.
It might be reassuring to believe that Hanssen acted alone. But if that
is the case, he would likely have repented and confessed all. The
opposite reaction -- his stony silence -- indicates something other than
the sins of a prodigal son.
Hanssen's one-word explanation for his treason, according to an FBI
affidavit, was "loyalty." It may well be that his loyalty -- to Opus Dei
and, by extension, the foreign service of the Vatican state -- hold the
key to the mystery.
Opus Dei, Latin for "Work of God," is a secretive lay group within the
body of the Catholic Church, with more than 80,000 members worldwide. As
the only personal prelature in the Church, it is an entity unto itself,
separate from the diocesan structure.
Founded in the late 1920s by Spanish priest Josemaria Escriva, Opus Dei
assumed a political role from the start, openly siding with the Franco
dictatorship. Its members served in cabinets while Spain was allied with
Hitler and Mussolini.
Opus Dei floundered in the wake of World War II, but regained impetus
under Pope John Paul II, after providing crucial support for his papal
candidacy. In the Polish pope, the group found a champion willing to back
its harsh stance against abortion, birth control, its crusade against
communism, the push for Catholicism as a state religion, and war on
left-leaning liberation theologians within the church.
It may seem paradoxical that Hanssen would spy for the Soviet Union, a
moral adversary and indeed a satanic force in the eyes of Opus Dei.
During Gorbachev's glasnost era, however, there is evidence of
behind-the-scenes collaboration between the Vatican and Moscow. In
particular, Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Agostino Casaroli, a
powerful Opus Dei supporter, pursued a policy of reaching out toward
Moscow with the aim of gaining Poland's release from the Warsaw Pact.
Rivers of money, much of it provided by Bill Casey's CIA, poured into
Warsaw and Moscow, and the Vatican found ready support from the U.S.
because the security establishment under President Ronald Reagan was
packed with conservative Catholics, including Casey, Richard Allen and
William Clark.
Hanssen's most damaging activities in FBI counterintelligence coincided
with these years, 1985-89. Secrets from America's intelligence vaults
could well have been part of the quid pro quo in the late cardinal's
dance with Moscow.
Certainly, the Vatican has had no qualms about violating American
sensitivities. Indeed, it seems to reflect a Eurocentric triumphalism.
The papal encyclical on labor rights slapped rampant materialism -- that
is, the immoral United States -- as the "other" great evil afoot in the
world.
The Vatican's political work with Moscow paid off handsomely with the
independence of Catholic-dominant Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Ukraine and
later, from Moscow's nominal ally Yugoslavia, of Slovenia and Croatia.
All the while, Hanssen kept up the flow of U.S. secrets to Moscow.
Why might a conscientious Catholic be accused of betraying the FBI's
Russian recruits to the firing squad? Hanssen has spoken of his schoolboy
fascination with a book about Kim Philby, Britain's notorious turncoat
spy (a claim flawed by the fact that "The Philby Conspiracy" was
published after Hanssen graduated from high school).
But Hanssen may well have read John LeCarre's 1974 "Tinker, Tailor,
Soldier, Spy," based on the Philby saga, in which a high-ranking mole
betrays his fellow agents in order to advance his career inside the
British intelligence bureaucracy. As Moscow rolls up their spy rings, his
rivals, one by one, lose their chances for promotion, while the double
agent becomes the golden boy headed for the pinnacle of power.
The plot of "Tinker, Tailor" bears a disturbing resemblance to the recent
chaos inside U.S. intelligence. Did Hanssen clear the path to the FBI
directorate for his fellow Opus Dei member Louis Freeh? This possibility
cannot be dismissed, nor should reluctance to interfere with a religious
organization prevent a probe into Hanssen's ties within Opus Dei.
In nearly every case involving a secretive sect, like the Branch
Davidians or Aum Shinrikyo, law enforcement authorities have erred on the
side of acting too slowly.
For the faithful, the response to the Hanssen affair should not be
limited to sermons about a lost sheep tangled in Satan's snares. Opus
Dei, models itself after the Counter-Reformation, appears to be repeating
the worst mistakes from that chapter of church history. As the church
became engrossed in the fates of nations, its moral certitude against
Protestant dissent was lost. The institutional paranoia of the
Inquisition gave rise to the secret police of Cardinal Richelieu who were
at the service of the state.
That attempt to remold the state into the image of the church resulted in
its very opposite, the French Revolution.

Pacific News Service,
660 Market Street, Room 210, San Francisco, CA 94104,
tel: (415) 438-4755.
Jinn Magazine: <http://www.pacificnews.org/jinn/>
Email:
<pacificnews@pacificnews.org>
Copyright © 1900 Pacific News Service. All Rights Reserved.
Please do not reprint our stories without our permission.
This article is available for reprint.
For rates and information, call (415) 438-4755 or e-mail
<pacificnews@pacificnews.org>
|