Basis for the Prediction:
In a recent interview with Jane Perlez of the New York Times
shortly before the Democratic national convention President
Clinton described the region encompassing Afghanistan, Kashmir
and the Central Asian heartland to the north as the most volatile
in the world.
At first it seemed he was mainly pointing at Kashmir where
the bloodshed rate is steadily rising. The Times' headline
was Clinton urges Pakistan to go easy on Kashmir. But a look
at the larger picture shows that presidential concern went
beyond Kashmir. A major White House foreign policy is facing
final collapse even as Clinton, at the convention, hailed
the many successes of his eight years in office.
The dying policy was directed towards Afghanistan. During
the last century the British, who ruled India and feared Russian
expansion, were fond of saying "who controls Afghanistan controls
the world." At the time the Anglo-Russian rivalry centered
on Afghanistan was called the "Great Game." In the wake of
the disintegration of the Soviet Union the term made a comeback.
It appears that Clinton, voracious reader that he is, agrees
that poor, war-ravaged but fiercely Islamic Afghanistan is
at the center of today's Great Game.
In 1525 Babur Shah, descendant of Genghis Khan and Tamerlane,
launched his conquest of India from Kabul. Now there is fear
in Moscow, New Delhi, Beijing, Islamabad and, of course, Washington
that the reclusive Taliban leader Mullah Omar, styled Commander
of the Faithful, could become another Babur, or worse, the
Caliph Omar, the second to bear the title Commander of the
Faithful. From 634 to 644 Omar's new Muslim soldiers brought
down the Persian and gravely weakened the Byzantine empires.
Like the early Muslims a millennium and a half ago the Taliban
hold that there are no nations, races or tribes, only those
who believe in one God and those who do not. Many people in
the region and beyond see this "fundamentalism" as a source
of hope. It also enabled the Taliban to take over 90 percent
of the country with minimal loss of life. Whenever the Taliban
showed up the enemy troops deserted their warlord commanders
and joined them.
What the American public most knows about Afghanistan is
that the Taliban have given refuge to Osama Bin Laden, billed
in the Western media as the world's number one terrorist.
Last year the Clinton administration adopted a new Afghanistan
policy based on one key premise: there was a way to pressure
the ruling Taliban to hand him over to the US.
Osama Bin Laden comes from a prominent Saudi family. When
he joined the Afghan Mujahideen to fight against the Soviet
occupiers he was regarded as a hero throughout the Islamic
world but also in Washington. When the Russians left, the
Mujadhideen leaders turned into warlords battling each other.
Osama left Afghanistan and sought refuge in fundamentalist
Sudan. When the Taliban succeeded in routing all but one of
the warlords and taking 90 percent of the country Osama was
given refuge by Mullah Omar.
Washington's new policy centered on so isolating Afghanistan
from the world community that simply to survive, feed their
people and give them jobs that they would have no choice but
to hand Osama over. But if they did that Commander of the
Faithful the Mullah Omar would be shown as a pious fraud.
The spirit would go out of Islamic revolutionary movements
all over the world.
The one warlord who remained was Ahmed Shah Mas'ud. He held
the strategic Panjsheer Valley only some 50 miles from the
capital Kabul. From time to time he would lob shells into
Kabul to show he was still a threat. What made him a credible
threat was an Afghan "Ho Chi Minh" trail that went down to
the Panjsheer from Tajikistan, now an independent nation but
whose borders are still guarded by Russian troops. As a result
Russian weaponry and supplies kept coming down the trail to
Mas'ud's stronghold.
So confidant was the Clinton White House that Mas'ud could
not be defeated that recently an official of the State Department
upgraded the amount of terrain Mas'ud held from 10 to 15 percent.
"There is no way Mas'ud can be defeated," he said publicly,
a statement prominently cited in media serving the sizeable
Afghan communities in the US.
If Mas'ud indeed had been in unshakeable control of that
15 percent the Taliban would have been in terrible straits.
People are starving. There are no jobs. The great powers have
cut one international Afghan link to the outside world after
the other.
The Taliban are already besieging his stronghold on two sides.
He cannot use the Russian-built tunnel leading to the north.
That leaves only the trail. But now the Taliban have overrun
the trailhead areas in the north leading to the Tajik border.
And it is highly unlikely, given their disastrous defeat in
Afghanistan, their "Vietnam," Russian soldiers will be sent
in to reopen the trail.
The last of the warlords is on the ropes. Mullah Omar has
asked Mas'ud to join the Taliban, the only condition being
that he accept the Mullah as Commander of the Faithful. Without
Mas'ud, the Clinton policy on Afghanistan is dead.
The Taliban's final victory will lead to even more bloodshed
in Kashmir. A Central Asia wide Islamic movement is operating
out of Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan. Most worried is the region's
biggest country, Uzbekistan. China is equally worried about
Islamic fundamentalism in its far western Xinjiang province.
The authorities recently carried out public executions of
Muslim "separatists." And not only are the Russians once again
bogged down in Islamic Chechnya but war is spreading to neighboring
Islamic Dagestan. More and more Russians are worried about
terrorist acts like the recent Moscow subway bombing.
In 1918, right after World War I, a powerful movement, atheistic
Communism, spread out like a prairie fire from revolutionary
Russia. In 1917 there were no communist parties anywhere.
In 1919 scores were sprouting up all over the world. They
preached there are no nations, races or tribes, only those
who are workers or peasants and those who are not. In 1840
there was no Christianity in China. In 1850 a movement called
the Taiping, the Great Peace, conquered two thirds of the
country led by a man who considered himself the younger brother
of Jesus Christ. The Taipings too preached absolute equality
of all people.
Sometimes history does repeat itself.
Return to the Predictions
Page